Crumbl Everything But The Dad Jokes Cookie: Price, Ingredients & Allergens

One of Crumbl’s most whimsical and indulgent cookies is the Crumbl Everything But The Dad Jokes Cookie. This over-the-top cookie is made of soft original cookie dough with a lot of colorful candy pieces and peanut butter chips and is served warm. Then it’s finished off with a pool of melted peanut butter, crunchy peanut butter-coated potato chips and even more candy for extra sweets and texture.

It’s a cookie for dessert lovers who like to kick things up a notch with every bite, and appreciate a blend of sweet, salty, creamy, and crunchy flavors. The cookie is unique in that it offers something different from a traditional cookie, from the rich peanut butter topping to the surprising potato chip crunch.

Everything But The Dad Jokes Cookie

Crumbl Everything But The Dad Jokes Cookie

An original cookie packed with candy pieces and peanut butter chips, topped with a melted peanut butter pool and crunchy peanut butter-coated potato chips, and finished with pops of more candy pieces.

Crumbl Everything But The Dad Jokes Cookie Prices

ItemEstimated Price
Single$4.49
4-Pack Box$16.69
6-Pack Box$23.29
12-Pack Box$43.99
Party PackVaries by location

Everything But The Dad Jokes Cookie Ingredients

Ingredient CategoryIngredients
Cookie BaseWheat flour, sugar, butter, eggs
Mix-InsCandy pieces, peanut butter chips
Peanut Butter ToppingMelted peanut butter pool
Crunch ToppingPeanut butter-coated potato chips
SweetenersGranulated sugar, brown sugar
Dairy ComponentsButter, milk ingredients
Baking EssentialsVanilla extract, salt
Leavening AgentsBaking soda, baking powder

Flavor Profile Breakdown

Flavor ElementIntensityDescription
Peanut ButterVery HighDominant throughout the cookie
SweetnessHighCandy pieces and peanut butter chips add richness
SaltinessMedium-HighPotato chips provide a savory contrast
Crunch FactorHighCandy pieces and coated chips add texture
Buttery NotesMediumRich cookie foundation
Candy FlavorMedium-HighSweet bursts throughout each bite
Overall IndulgenceVery HighA loaded dessert experience

Estimated Nutrition Information

NutrientEstimated Amount
Calories750 kcal
Total Fat39g
Saturated Fat14g
Cholesterol70mg
Sodium480mg
Total Carbohydrates90g
Dietary Fiber3g
Total Sugars55g
Protein12g

Nutrition values are estimated based on ingredient composition and comparable Crumbl specialty cookies.

Calories Distribution Chart

Nutrient SourceApproximate Contribution
Carbohydrates48%
Fat45%
Protein7%

Estimated Calorie Breakdown

SourceCalories
Carbohydrates360 kcal
Fat338 kcal
Protein52 kcal
Total750 kcal

Allergen Information

AllergenPresent
Milkโœ“
Eggโœ“
Wheatโœ“
Soyโœ“
Peanutsโœ“

Potential Cross-Contact Allergens

Because Crumbl products are prepared in shared bakery environments, this cookie may also come into contact with:

  • Peanuts
  • Tree Nuts
  • Milk
  • Eggs
  • Wheat
  • Soy
  • Sesame

Individuals with severe food allergies should review Crumbl’s official allergen information before purchasing.

Best For Which Type of Cookie Lovers?

  • Peanut butter enthusiasts
  • Sweet-and-salty dessert fans
  • Candy lovers
  • Customers who enjoy loaded cookies
  • Fans of unique flavor combinations
  • People who love crunchy toppings
  • Anyone looking for a fun, indulgent treat

Who Should Avoid This Cookie?

  • Individuals with peanut allergies
  • People allergic to milk, eggs, wheat, or soy
  • Customers following low-sugar diets
  • Those limiting calorie intake
  • People who prefer simple cookie flavors
  • Anyone who dislikes sweet-and-salty combinations

Texture & Serving Experience

Another one of the greatest features of the Everything But The Dad Jokes Cookie is its great diversity of textures. The base of these cookies is warm, soft, and chewy, which is enhanced by the crunch and creaminess of the toppings.

Texture Breakdown

ComponentTexture
Cookie BaseSoft and chewy
Peanut Butter PoolSmooth and creamy
Candy PiecesSlight crunch and chew
Peanut Butter ChipsSoft and rich
Potato ChipsCrunchy and salty
Overall BiteSweet, salty, crunchy, and gooey

Serving Experience

When heated, the peanut butter topping is soft and melty, and integrates with the cookie base. The candy pieces will bring a sweetness kick, while the peanut butter covered potato chips will give it a salty crunch kick to balance out the rich flavors. Each bite offers a variety of textures and makes for an exciting cookie from start to finish.

Final Verdict

Crumbl Everything But The Dad Jokes Cookie is a fun name for a cookie that’s packed with just about every dessert texture and flavor one could expect. With candy pieces, peanut butter chips, melted peanut butter topping and crunchy peanut butter coated potato chips it gives an indelible sweet-salty taste.

At 750 calories, it’s certainly an indulgent treat, but for peanut butter fans and lovers of loaded cookies, it may be one of the most exciting offerings on the Crumbl menu.