Explore Crumbl Peanut Butter Milkshake Cookie ft. Butterfinger®: Price, Calories, Allergens & More
The Peanut Butter Milkshake Cookie ft. Butterfinger® is a chilled peanut butter cookie rolled in Butterfinger® pieces, topped with Butterfinger®-studded peanut butter buttercream, whipped cream, and a finishing Butterfinger® crunch. Butterfinger® is a trademark of Ferrero Group.
- Served: Chilled
- Calories: 840 per full cookie (about 210 per quarter)
- Typical price:~$4.99 (varies by store)
- Contains: Milk, Peanuts, Egg, Wheat, Soy
Crumbl Peanut Butter Milkshake Cookie ft. Butterfinger® Prices
| Item | Estimated Price |
|---|---|
| Single Cookie | $4.49 |
| 4-Pack Box | $16.99 |
| 6-Pack Box | $24.99 |
| 12-Pack Box | $35.99 |
| Party Pack | Varies by location |
Pricing may vary depending on the Crumbl store location and delivery platform fees.
Crumbl Peanut Butter Milkshake Cookie ft. Butterfinger® Ingredients
| Component | What it adds |
|---|---|
| Peanut butter cookie | Chilled, nutty base |
| Butterfinger® pieces | Crunchy candy rolled into the dough |
| Peanut butter buttercream | Creamy layer studded with candy |
| Whipped cream | Milkshake-style topping |
| Butterfinger® crunch | Final crunchy topping |
Components come from Crumbl’s own menu description. Crumbl says its desserts are made from scratch daily with flour, sugar, butter, eggs and chocolate. A full ingredient statement is in the Crumbl app.
Flavor Profile Breakdown
| Trait | Details |
|---|---|
| Flavor | Peanut butter, crisp candy, sweet cream |
| Texture | Soft cookie, creamy topping, crunchy bits |
| Served | Chilled |
| Style | Milkshake-inspired cookie |
| Best for | Peanut butter lovers |
The milkshake idea shows in the whipped cream and buttercream, while Butterfinger® adds crunch throughout.
At 840 calories it is the second-highest in this set. Peanut butter raises fat and protein compared with the flour-and-fruit cookies.
Estimated Nutrition Information
| Item | Amount |
|---|---|
| Calories (full cookie) | 840 cal |
| Calories per quarter cookie | about 210 cal |
| % of a 2,000-calorie day | about 42% |
| Estimated fat / carbs / protein | about 49 g / 80 g / 21 g |
Calories are Crumbl’s listed figure. Crumbl’s app often shows nutrition per quarter cookie, so always multiply by four. The gram figures are estimates worked back from the split below, not an official label. It is the only cookie of the seven that lists peanuts as an ingredient.
Calories Distribution Chart
cal
Estimated split. Total calories are Crumbl’s listed figure; verify exact macros in the Crumbl app.
Allergen Information
Contains: Milk, Peanuts, Egg, Wheat, Soy.
| Allergen | Status |
|---|---|
| Milk | Yes |
| Egg | Yes |
| Wheat | Yes |
| Soy | Yes |
| Peanuts | Yes |
| Tree Nuts | Listed as a general kitchen risk |
| Sesame Seeds | Listed as a general kitchen risk |
| Fish | Listed as a general kitchen risk |
| Crustacean shellfish | Listed as a general kitchen risk |
Crumbl makes its desserts on site, so any item may touch other allergens during production, including peanuts, tree nuts, milk, eggs, wheat, soy and sesame. This is the only flavor here that contains peanuts, so avoid it if you have a peanut allergy. If you have a severe allergy, confirm with your store and the Crumbl app before ordering.
Good to know
Does it contain peanuts?
Yes, it is listed as an ingredient.
Is Butterfinger® made by Crumbl?
No. It is a trademark of Ferrero Group.
Sources: Crumbl Cookies official site and store menus (crumblcookies.com); Crumbl’s published allergy statement; price ranges from 2026 third-party price guides; serving-size convention reported by Newsweek. Menus rotate weekly, so availability and numbers can change. This post is independent and not affiliated with Crumbl.